Updated for 2026: I originally published this comparison in April 2017. A lot has changed in WordPress and email marketing since then. Some of the tools from the original list disappeared or evolved, while others—surprisingly—are still going strong. I’ve completely revisited the list for 2026 rather than simply updating a few old screenshots and prices.
7 Best WordPress List Building Plugins Compared (2026)
Originally published April 30, 2017. Completely updated for 2026.
Building an email list is still one of the most valuable things you can do with a WordPress site.
I originally published this comparison back in 2017. Looking at it again nearly a decade later was interesting. Some of the tools I covered have changed dramatically, some have essentially been replaced, and a few are remarkably still going strong.
So rather than changing a few prices and calling the article updated, I decided to revisit the subject from scratch.
The question is still the same:
What’s the best WordPress list building plugin for turning website visitors into email subscribers?
The answer depends on what you’re trying to accomplish. Some site owners want sophisticated targeting and A/B testing. Others just need a simple signup form that works. And if you’re already paying for a WordPress ecosystem such as Elementor or Elegant Themes, you may already have much of what you need.
Here are seven options I’d consider today.
Quick Comparison
| Tool | Best For | Free Option | A/B Testing | Advanced Targeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thrive Leads | Serious WordPress marketers | No | Yes | Yes |
| OptinMonster | Advanced targeting and campaigns | Limited option | Yes, plan dependent | Yes |
| Popup Maker | Flexible free WordPress option | Yes | Premium features available | Premium features available |
| Bloom | Elegant Themes/Divi users | No | Yes | Yes |
| Elementor Pro | Sites already using Elementor | No | Limited compared with dedicated tools | Yes |
| Hustle | Budget-conscious site owners | Yes | Varies by version/plan | Yes |
| Email provider forms | Simple list building | Often | Provider dependent | Provider dependent |
Features and pricing change frequently, so verify the current plan before purchasing.
1. Thrive Leads
It’s fitting that Thrive Leads remains on this list.
When I originally wrote this article in 2017, Thrive Leads was my first choice. Nearly a decade later, Thrive is still developing it.
Thrive Leads is designed specifically around building an email list from a WordPress website rather than being a general-purpose form plugin. It lets you create different types of opt-in forms and control where and when they’re displayed.
Its real appeal is the marketing functionality. If you want to experiment with different offers, designs and placements rather than simply putting a newsletter box in your sidebar, Thrive Leads is built for that type of work.
Best for: WordPress site owners who take conversion optimization seriously and want their list-building tools closely integrated with WordPress.
What I like: Strong targeting, testing and conversion-oriented features without requiring you to build your entire email list strategy around a basic contact-form plugin.
Potential downside: It’s probably more than you need if all you want is a simple newsletter signup box.
2. OptinMonster
OptinMonster has become one of the best-known names in conversion optimization since this article was originally published.
It’s particularly strong when you want to control who sees an offer and when they see it.
Instead of displaying the same signup form to everyone, you can build campaigns around visitor behavior and different parts of your site. That’s useful for larger sites where someone reading one type of content may be interested in a completely different lead magnet from someone reading another.
The tradeoff is that OptinMonster operates more like a conversion-marketing platform than a simple WordPress plugin.
Best for: Businesses and marketers who want sophisticated targeting, multiple campaign types and conversion optimization.
What I like: The depth of targeting and campaign options.
Potential downside: If you’re running a small blog and just want to collect email addresses, you may be paying for sophistication you don’t actually need.
3. Popup Maker
If cost matters, Popup Maker deserves serious consideration.
Unlike many tools in this category, there is a genuinely useful free WordPress plugin at its core. It currently has more than 700,000 active installations, and development remains active. WordPress.org
Despite the name, it isn’t limited to annoying popups appearing in the middle of someone’s screen. It can be used for opt-ins, slide-ins, banners, modal windows and other calls to action.
You can start relatively simply and add more sophisticated functionality if you need it.
Best for: WordPress users who want flexibility without immediately committing to another subscription.
What I like: You can start free, it’s WordPress-native, and it has a large established user base.
Potential downside: Some of the more sophisticated conversion and targeting capabilities require paid functionality.
4. Bloom
Bloom is another survivor from my original 2017 comparison.
It’s made by Elegant Themes, the company behind Divi, and remains particularly attractive if you’re already paying for that ecosystem.
Bloom supports several opt-in form types and includes targeting, statistics and A/B testing. That makes it considerably more capable than simply embedding a newsletter form in your sidebar.
Best for: Divi and Elegant Themes users.
What I like: If you’re already an Elegant Themes customer, adding another completely separate list-building platform may be unnecessary.
Potential downside: I wouldn’t necessarily join the Elegant Themes ecosystem solely to get Bloom. Its value proposition is strongest when you’re already using their products.
5. Elementor Pro
This one illustrates how much WordPress has changed since I wrote the original article.
You don’t necessarily need a dedicated “list building plugin” anymore.
If you’re already building your site with Elementor Pro, its form and popup functionality may cover much of what you’re trying to accomplish. Elementor currently provides subscribe forms, mailing-list and CRM integrations, popup triggers, slide-ins and other marketing tools. Elementor
That’s important because every additional WordPress plugin adds another thing to maintain.
Best for: Sites already built with Elementor Pro.
What I like: You’re using tools already integrated into your page-building workflow rather than installing another large marketing system.
Potential downside: I wouldn’t buy Elementor solely for list building. Dedicated conversion tools can also provide more sophisticated testing and targeting.
6. Hustle
Hustle is worth considering if you’re looking for an accessible way to experiment with list building without immediately committing to one of the more expensive platforms.
It supports opt-in forms and other conversion-focused elements and can work well for smaller WordPress sites that want more than a plain signup form but don’t need an enterprise-level marketing platform.
Best for: Bloggers and small site owners who want to experiment with different opt-in approaches while keeping costs under control.
What I like: It occupies a useful middle ground between extremely basic signup forms and expensive conversion platforms.
Potential downside: More advanced marketers may eventually outgrow it or prefer the testing and targeting capabilities of a dedicated conversion platform.
7. Your Email Provider’s Own WordPress Forms
Here’s the option I probably wouldn’t have included when I originally wrote this article:
You may not need a separate list-building plugin at all.
Most modern email platforms provide signup forms or WordPress integrations of their own.
If you’re using a service such as Kit, MailerLite, Mailchimp or another email platform, start by looking at what it already provides.
For a new site, that’s often enough.
There’s little reason to install a complicated conversion system before you even have enough traffic to meaningfully test one form against another.
Best for: New sites and anyone who values simplicity.
What I like: Fewer plugins, fewer moving parts and potentially no additional expense.
Potential downside: You generally won’t get the same depth of targeting, testing and campaign design available from dedicated conversion tools.
So Which WordPress List Building Plugin Should You Choose?
I don’t think there’s one plugin that’s best for everyone.
If I wanted a serious WordPress-native conversion system, Thrive Leads would be near the top of my list.
For sophisticated behavioral targeting and campaigns, I’d look closely at OptinMonster.
If I wanted to start free and retain plenty of flexibility, Popup Maker would be one of my first choices. Its current WordPress listing shows 700,000+ active installations and continued development in 2026. WordPress.org
Already using Divi? I’d investigate Bloom before buying something else.
Already paying for Elementor Pro? Try its existing marketing tools first.
And if you’re just starting your email list, I’d begin with the forms supplied by your email provider before adding another layer of software.
That’s probably the biggest change in my thinking since I originally wrote this article in 2017.
Don’t choose the tool with the most features. Choose the simplest tool that does what you actually need.
Nine Years Later
Revisiting an article I first published in 2017 is a reminder of just how quickly the tools around an online business can change.
The underlying idea hasn’t changed nearly as much.
Your website traffic is temporary. Someone can discover you through Google, read one article and never return.
An email list gives you a way to continue that relationship.
That’s why, even after all these years, I still consider building an email list one of the more valuable things a website owner can do.